Cyber AssessValydex™by iFeelTech
Comparison Guide

Cisco Umbrella vs Cloudflare (2026)

Cloudflare is free to 50 users; Cisco Umbrella is in end-of-sale and Secure Access has no public price

Cloudflare Zero Trust is free for up to 50 users and $7 per user after. Cisco Umbrella is in end-of-sale. See costs, limits and which to pilot.

Last updated: October 27, 2026
11 minute read

Verdict: Cloudflare is the easier first pilot, Cisco is the quote to ask for if you already live in its world

For a US business with 5 to 100 staff, Cloudflare Zero Trust is the easier first pilot when the requirement is DNS filtering and someone on your team can own setup and monitoring. It publishes a free plan for up to 50 users and a pay-as-you-go plan at $7 per user per month, and a pilot costs nothing. The free plan has community-style support and up to 24 hours of standard log retention, and pay-as-you-go has chat and ticket support and up to 30 days, so those limits can matter more than the license price. Cisco deserves a quote when an existing Cisco or Meraki deployment, an MSP or a broader requirement makes the integration worthwhile. But Umbrella DNS and SIG are in end-of-sale, so a new Cisco buyer should price Cisco Secure Access, DNS Defense, not Umbrella, and Cisco does not publish a US price for it. Checked October 27, 2026.

Cisco announced Umbrella end-of-sale

Cisco's notice lists January 31, 2027 as the last day to order affected Umbrella DNS and SIG products, January 31, 2028 as the last day to renew or add to an existing subscription and January 31, 2029 as the last day of support. Confirm your own contract.

Your situationBetter fitWhyWhat reverses the answer
Under 50 staff, want DNS filtering, own the setupCloudflare Zero Trust Free$0 and a fast pilotYou need phone support or long logs
Existing Umbrella customerPlan the Cisco migrationSupport through January 2029You prefer to switch vendors at renewal
Cisco or Meraki shop, or an MSP runs CiscoQuote Secure Access DNS DefenseIntegration, partner supportCloudflare covers the need at lower effort
Over 50 users, narrow filtering needsCloudflare pay-as-you-go$7 per user, chat and ticket supportYour volume justifies a contract quote
Need private app access and inspectionQuote both on the full requirementDNS-only does not do theseYou only need domain blocking
Main gaps are patching, MFA or backupsFix those firstA DNS filter will not close themYou already have them covered

What each is, in plain terms

Cisco Umbrella is a cloud DNS-layer security service that evaluates domain requests before a connection is made. Its successor, Cisco Secure Access, is a security service edge platform with several packages: Secure Access Essentials and Advantage, which cover secure internet access and private access, and DNS Defense Essentials and Advantage for DNS-layer security. It is licensed per covered user on 12-, 36- or 60-month terms that renew automatically for 12 months, and Cisco Secure Client is required for client-based features.

Cloudflare Zero Trust is part of Cloudflare One. Its plan page lists a Free plan for up to 50 users, a Pay-as-you-go plan at $7 per user per month for teams over 50 users with narrow needs, and a Contract plan with annual custom pricing. The capabilities listed include a secure web gateway with DNS and HTTP filtering, zero trust network access, a device client, CASB, data loss prevention and remote browser isolation, with some of them as add-ons.

What it costs

ItemCisco Secure Access DNS DefenseCloudflare Zero Trust
Public US priceNot published; a reseller lists DNS Defense Essentials at $37.80 per user for one yearFree up to 50 users; $7 per user per month pay-as-you-go
MinimumDNS Defense lists a one-user minimum; Secure Internet and Private Access list a 50-user bandNone listed for Free
Term12, 36 or 60 months, automatic 12-month renewalMonthly for pay-as-you-go
SupportQuote and contract specificFree: community; pay-as-you-go: chat and ticket; contract: phone too
Standard logsQuote specificFree up to 24 hours; pay-as-you-go up to 30 days; contract up to 6 months with Logpush
Main risk for a new buyerBuying a retiring SKU without a migration planAssuming free means full support, long logs or every advanced feature

For Cloudflare, the list-price examples below are before tax and extras. DLP is charged separately, free for the first 10 GB and $1 per GB per month after on the free and pay-as-you-go plans.

Billable usersCloudflare Free, if suitableCloudflare pay-as-you-goCisco DNS Defense Essentials, reseller list
10$0$70 per month, $840 per year$378 per year
25$0$175 per month, $2,100 per year$945 per year
50$0$350 per month, $4,200 per year$1,890 per year

Cloudflare says its pay-as-you-go plan is best for teams over 50 users with narrow needs, so the 10 and 25-user figures are shown only as list arithmetic, not as a recommendation. The Cisco column is a reseller listing for one product at a one-year term and not a Cisco quote. For Cisco, request an itemized quote for 10, 25 and 50 covered users that names the package and SKU, the seat minimum, the term, support, log retention and export, onboarding labor, migration help and renewal price. A price for legacy Umbrella DNS Essentials cannot stand in for Secure Access DNS Defense.

Strengths of each, and where each falls short

Cisco Secure Access and Umbrella

Where it is strong

  • A well-known DNS and secure web gateway lineage with a large installed base and many MSPs
  • A path from DNS-only protection to private access and broader internet controls in one vendor
  • Fits Cisco and Meraki environments, with existing contracts supported until January 2029
  • Packaged support and contract terms suited to businesses that want a named vendor and partner

Where it falls short or costs more than it looks

  • Umbrella DNS and SIG are in end-of-sale, with new orders ending January 31, 2027
  • No published self-serve price, multi-year terms and automatic renewal
  • Roaming coverage and some features depend on Cisco Secure Client and the package quoted
  • A longer sales and setup process than a self-serve product

Cloudflare Zero Trust

Where it is strong

  • A published free plan for up to 50 users and a published pay-as-you-go price
  • A self-serve pilot you can run in a day, with DNS locations or a device client
  • A broad feature set that extends from DNS filtering to access, CASB and DLP as needs grow
  • A 100 percent uptime service level agreement listed for paid plans

Where it falls short or costs more than it looks

  • The free plan has community-style support and up to 24 hours of standard logs
  • Pay-as-you-go is positioned for teams over 50 users with narrow needs and does not include enterprise support services
  • Browser isolation, full DLP and long log retention are add-ons or contract features
  • Router-only DNS changes do not protect roaming laptops without the device client

DNS filtering is only the first layer

Both vendors can block known malicious domains. The useful question is where policy is enforced. Cloudflare supports a network DNS location or a client on an individual device. A router-only change covers devices using that network resolver and does not protect a laptop working elsewhere, and a DNS-only setup does not provide HTTP or network filtering. Cisco's DNS product describes on-network DNS forwarding and off-network protection through Cisco components including Secure Client. Treat an existing Meraki integration as a pilot advantage, not proof that every roaming endpoint is covered.

If a sales presentation promises zero-trust application access, encrypted web inspection, DLP or browser isolation, ask for the exact entitlement and prerequisites. These are different controls from domain blocking. Neither DNS service replaces endpoint protection, MFA or tested recovery.

Two illustrative scenarios

A 20-person consultancy, all laptops, no Cisco gear. The firm wants to block known-bad domains for office and remote staff and has an IT-minded partner who can spend an hour a month on it. Cloudflare Free is a sensible pilot: it costs nothing, and the device client covers laptops away from the office. The limits are community support and 24-hour logs, so the firm accepts that it will not have a long history to investigate with. If it later needs retention and phone support, it can quote pay-as-you-go or a contract.

A 70-person firm with a Meraki network and an MSP. The MSP already operates Cisco tools and the firm expects to renew its Umbrella subscription. Here the question is the migration, not a fresh shootout. The firm should ask the MSP for a written mapping from its part numbers to Secure Access, a price for the equivalent DNS Defense package, and a comparison with Cloudflare pay-as-you-go at 70 users, which is $490 a month or $5,880 a year at list. If the MSP's operational value is worth the difference, Cisco is reasonable. If not, switching is a technical task, not a political one.

A two-week pilot that reveals the real cost

  1. Write down the gap. List the domains or categories to block, the users and locations in scope, the log retention you need and the person who will review alerts and exceptions.
  2. Inventory the current stack. Record DNS filtering already provided by your firewall, MSP or an existing subscription, and list managed and unmanaged devices, off-network work and VPN paths.
  3. Set up a small test group. Include an office device and a roaming laptop, and confirm both appear in the logs before judging policy effectiveness.
  4. Test a block and a legitimate exception. Record the policy, time, user, escalation owner and recovery action. Do not start with a production-critical application.
  5. Test the limits. Check the support route, log visibility after one day, device enrollment failure, captive portal behavior and whether a second VPN or resolver bypasses policy.
  6. Price operations. Include subscription, any managed service, setup, ongoing review, log export and migration from a retiring Umbrella SKU.

For existing Umbrella customers, add a migration rehearsal. Ask Cisco or your MSP to map current policy and part numbers to Secure Access, then compare logs and exception behavior in a pilot.

Migrating off Umbrella without breaking things

If you are moving from Umbrella to either product, treat it as a change project with a rollback. Export your existing policies, categories, allowlists and identity mappings before you touch anything, because the old console is the only record of why a given site was allowed. Run the new filter in a monitoring or log-only mode for a week if the product supports it, so you can see what would have been blocked. Then move a pilot group, then a department, then everyone, and keep the old service running until the last group has been stable for a couple of weeks. Check that roaming devices, guest networks and any site with its own resolver are covered, because those are the paths that silently bypass a new filter. Update your offboarding and new-hire checklists so the client or location is part of the standard setup. Finally, cancel the old subscription deliberately, before auto-renewal, and make sure you are not stuck in a 36- or 60-month term for a retiring product.

Who should not buy either

Teams without an owner. A DNS filter creates a stream of small decisions: allow this site, block that category, why did this device stop reporting. If nobody owns them, staff learn to ask for exceptions informally and the policy decays.

Teams that want full web inspection from a DNS tool. A DNS filter blocks domains, not specific pages, files or encrypted content. If you need that, you are shopping for a secure web gateway or a broader platform, and the price and effort will be different.

Teams that already have the control. If your firewall filters DNS for the office and your endpoint product filters web destinations on laptops, test the gap before you add a service.

Teams with weaker basics. If you do not have MFA on email, tested backups or a patching routine, those will reduce risk more per dollar than a DNS filter.

What to watch after you choose

Whichever route you take, check three numbers each quarter. First, how many threats were blocked and from which devices, because a sudden drop can mean devices are no longer reporting rather than that attackers have gone away. Second, how many exception requests you receive and how long they take, since a rising count suggests the policy is too strict or the process too slow. Third, your total cost including staff time. If a free tool takes an hour a week to manage and a paid one takes ten minutes, the paid one may be cheaper in practice.

Alternatives: when to look at something else

  • Your firewall's built-in DNS or web filtering. Check what you already license. See our UniFi review.
  • A business VPN with DNS filtering. NordLayer Core includes DNS category filtering. See our NordLayer review.
  • Endpoint protection with web control. See our Defender for Business review.
  • Better fundamentals first. MFA, backups and patching come before another filter. Use the free assessment to prioritize.

Before you buy

  1. Decide whether you need DNS filtering, web inspection or private access, and write it down.
  2. For Cisco, get a written quote for Secure Access with SKUs, term and renewal. Do not buy a retiring Umbrella SKU for a long term.
  3. For Cloudflare, pilot the free plan with a roaming device and check the log and support limits against your needs.
  4. Name an owner for policy and exceptions.
  5. Compare total cost including staff time. The budget worksheet treats unknown quotes as unknown, not zero.

See our Cisco Umbrella review and Cisco pricing guide for more on the Cisco side.

Evidence and disclosure

This comparison is documentation-based and not a hands-on test. Sources checked October 27, 2026: Cisco's end-of-sale notice and Secure Access ordering guide, Cisco's DNS product pages, Cloudflare's Zero Trust plan page and reseller listings for the Cisco price. The links above go to official pages, and we have not verified an affiliate relationship with either vendor, so none is assumed. See our research methodology and affiliate disclosure.

Frequently asked questions

Check whether DNS filtering is your next step

Find out whether DNS filtering, MFA or backups should come first.

Start the free assessment

Prices and dates were checked on October 27, 2026. Confirm plans, SKUs and totals before you buy.